Battle of the Lashes: Length or Volume?

When you're hunting for the perfect mascara, there are always trade-offs: length vs volume, dramatic vs natural, long-wear vs easy removal. Mary Kay has two strong offerings in this space: Great Heights Mascara, which focuses on extreme length, and Lash Love Fanorama Mascara, which promises a more voluminous, fanned-out lash look. I put these two side by side to see what each does best and to help you decide which might be your go-to.

Mary Kay’s Great Heights Mascara is all about sky-high length with a lightweight feel. Designed with a precision brush that grabs even the tiniest lashes, this formula builds beautifully without clumping or weighing lashes down. Just one coat gives noticeable length, while additional layers add dramatic extension and definition. It’s ophthalmologist-tested, suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, and delivers up to 12 hours of smudge-free wear. If you love a clean, separated lash look with length that seems to stretch toward the sky, Great Heights is your perfect everyday go-to.

For those who crave bold drama, Lash Love Fanorama Mascara delivers volume and flair with its unique three-zone brush. Each swipe coats, combs, and fans out lashes to create a full, panoramic effect that makes eyes pop. The Lash Love formula not only builds volume but also keeps lashes defined and fluttery rather than weighed down. This mascara is perfect for anyone who wants their lashes to make a statement—whether you’re heading out for a night on the town or just love a glam, fanned-out lash look. Fanorama brings the fullness, drama, and lash impact that turns heads.

---

Side-by-Side Comparison

Here are some comparison points that can help you choose quicker:

• If you want just one, which to pick? If your priority is length with lightness, go with Great Heights. If you favor volume and drama, Fanorama is the better bet.

• Layering potential: Great Heights layers better without looking heavy. Fanorama needs more careful layering; one heavy coat can cause clumps.

• Cost / Value: They are similarly priced within Mary Kay’s lineup. Given the stronger volume payoff, Fanorama might seem like more “bang for the buck” if you want bold lashes, but you’ll use more product with thicker layering.

• Suitability: Great Heights might suit sensitive eyes more, or those who wear contacts, especially if volume formulas tend to irritate them.

My Verdict

While both mascaras deliver on Mary Kay’s promise of quality and performance, they shine in different ways. Great Heights Mascara focuses on sleek, elongated lashes that feel weightless and natural, while Lash Love Fanorama is all about bold volume and a show-stopping, fanned-out effect. Choosing between them really comes down to what kind of lash look you want...subtle length for everyday wear or dramatic fullness for a more glamorous statement.

If I were to pick based on different priorities, here’s what I’d recommend:

• For daily wear / subtle but noticeable shine & length → Great Heights

• For nights out, photos, bold looks → Fanorama

• For people with short lashes → Great Heights gives length, and you can layer lightly.

• For people with sparse lashes or who love volume → Fanorama delivers more fullness and dramatic impact.

Tips to Get the Best Out of Each

• For Great Heights, start at the root, wiggle slightly, then pull to tip; one coat gives a lot. Use a lash comb afterward if needed.

• For Fanorama, clean off excess product on the wand tip before applying; maybe apply first coat lightly, then build up. Use the comb section on the wand carefully to avoid bunching.

• Always curl lashes first (if that’s your routine), and remove gently with an oil-based remover or dual phase, especially with volume mascaras.

Both Great Heights and Fanorama are solid Mary Kay mascaras, but they serve slightly different needs. Great Heights is your go-to when length, lightweight feel, and natural-but-enhanced lashes are the goal. Fanorama is more of a power mascara: bold, voluminous, and dramatic.

If you depend on only one in your beauty bag, consider what you do most (everyday wear or glam occasions) and pick accordingly. Or keep both, layering or switching depending on what look you want.

In the end, whether you’re Team Length or Team Volume, Mary Kay has you covered. Great Heights Mascara is the everyday essential for those who love fluttery, elongated lashes that look effortlessly natural. Meanwhile, Lash Love Fanorama is your go-to when you want to turn up the drama with bold, voluminous lashes that truly stand out. The best part? You don’t have to choose! Keep both in your beauty bag and switch them up depending on your mood, your look, or the occasion. With these two lash powerhouses, every day can be a good lash day.

Message me for your mascara or grab them at https://www.marykay.com/kkincergalloway

Love,

Kristen